What’s the Difference Between Store-Bought and Custom-Fit Mouthguards?

Whether you’re gearing up for sports, grinding your teeth at night, or just want to protect your smile, a mouthguard can make a huge difference. But if you’ve ever walked down the dental aisle at the store, you know there are plenty of options—and it’s not always clear which one is best. At Edgewood Family Dentistry in Anderson, Dr. Mallory Kuiper helps patients understand the difference between over-the-counter mouthguards and custom-fit ones made by your dentist.

The Appeal of Store-Bought Mouthguards

Store-bought mouthguards are popular because they’re easy to find and affordable. They come in two basic styles: ready-to-wear or boil-and-bite. While they provide some protection, they often feel bulky or slip out of place. For athletes, that can be distracting. For people who grind their teeth at night, it can mean restless sleep or waking up with jaw pain because the guard isn’t staying where it should.

The Advantages of Custom-Fit Mouthguards

A custom-fit mouthguard is designed specifically for your mouth. Dr. Kuiper takes impressions (or digital scans), and the guard is crafted to match your teeth perfectly. The result? A mouthguard that:

Fits snugly and stays put

Is thinner and more comfortable to wear

Makes it easier to breathe and speak while in use

Provides stronger protection against injuries or grinding damage

Patients often say the difference is night and day—once you try a custom mouthguard, it’s hard to go back.

Comfort Really Counts

The biggest reason people stop wearing their mouthguard is discomfort. If it feels too big, too awkward, or makes it tough to breathe, chances are it’ll end up sitting in a drawer. A custom mouthguard solves that problem by being both protective and comfortable—so you’ll actually use it when you need it most.

Protecting Smiles at Edgewood Family Dentistry in Anderson, IN

Your smile deserves the best protection, whether it’s on the field, on the court, or while you sleep. At Edgewood Family Dentistry, Dr. Mallory Kuiper provides custom-fit mouthguards that keep your teeth safe and your jaw more comfortable. If you’ve been relying on a store-bought guard—or skipping one altogether—call our Anderson office or schedule an appointment online. We’ll help you get a mouthguard that feels right and does its job well.

Contact Us

Categorised in: Custom Mouthguards